reader comments
64 with
My recent feature on passkeys attracted significant interest, and a number of the 1,100-plus comments raised questions about how the passkey system actually works and if it can be trusted. In response, I’ve put together this list of frequently asked questions to dispel a few myths and shed some light on what we know—and don’t know—about passkeys.
Q: I don’t trust Google. Why should I use passkeys?
A: If you don’t use Google, then Google passkeys aren’t for you. If you don’t use Apple or Microsoft products, the situation is similar. The original article was aimed at the hundreds of millions of people who do use these major platforms (even if grudgingly).
That said, passkey usage is quickly expanding beyond the major tech players. Within a month or two, for instance, 1Password and other third parties will support passkey syncing that will populate the credential to all your trusted devices. While Google is further along than any other service in allowing logins with passkeys, new services allow users to log in to their accounts with passkeys just about every week. In short order, you can use passkeys even if you don’t trust Google, Apple, or Microsoft.
Q: I don’t trust any company to sync my login credentials; I only keep them stored on my local devices. Why would I ever use passkeys?
A: Even if you don’t trust any cloud service to sync your login credentials, the FIDO specs allow for something called single-device passkeys. As the name suggests, these passkeys work on a single device and aren’t synced through any service. Single-device passkeys are typically created using a FIDO2 security key, such as a Yubikey.
However, if you’re syncing passwords through a browser, a password manager, iCloud Keychain, or one of the Microsoft or Google equivalents, be aware that you are already trusting a cloud service to sync your credentials. If you don’t trust cloud services to sync passkeys, you shouldn’t trust them to sync your passwords, either.
Q: It seems incredibly risky to sync passkeys. Why should I trust syncing from any service?
A: Currently, the FIDO specifications don’t strictly mandate syncing with end-to-end encryption, which by definition means nothing other than one of the trusted end-user devices has access to the private key in unencrypted (that is, usable) form. Apple’s syncing mechanism, for instance, relies on the same end-to-end encryption that iCloud Keychain already uses for password syncing. Apple has documented the design of this service in great detail here, here, here, here, and here. Independent security experts have yet to report any discrepancies in Apple’s claim that it lacks the means to unlock the credentials stored in the iCloud Keychain.
here. 1Password has documentation on the infrastructure that it uses to sync passwords (here and here). Again, if you already trust any cloud-based password syncing platform, it’s a little late to ask for documentation now. There’s little, if any, added risk to sync passkeys as well.
Q: Wasn’t there a recent article about new macOS malware that could steal iCloud Keychain items?
A: This may be a reference to MacStealer, malware that was recently advertised in underground crime forums. There are no reports of MacStealer being used in the wild, and there’s no confirmation that the malware even exists. We only know of ads claiming that such malware exists.
That said, the ad hawking MacStealer says it’s in early beta and comes in the form of a standard DMG file that must be manually installed on a Mac. The DMG file is not digitally signed, so it won’t install unless an end user mucks around in the macOS security settings. Even then, a victim would have to go on to enter their iCloud password into the app after it’s installed before cloud-based data could be extracted.
Based on the description of MacStealer from Uptycs, the security firm that spotted the ad, I don’t think people have much to worry about. And even if the malware does pose a threat, that threat extends not just to passkeys but to anything else that hundreds of millions of people already store in iCloud Keychain.
Q: Passkeys give control of your credentials to Apple/Google/Microsoft, to a third-party syncing service, or to the site you’re logging in to. Why would I ever do that?
A: Assuming you’re using a password to sign in to a service such as Gmail, Azure, or Github, you’re already trusting these companies to implement their authentication systems in a way that doesn’t expose the shared secrets that allow you to log in. Logging in to one of these sites with a passkey instead of a password gives the sites the same control—no more and no less—over your credentials than they had before.
The reason is that the private key portion of a passkey never leaves a user’s encrypted devices. The authentication occurs on the user device. The user device then sends the site being logged into a cryptographic proof that the private key resides on the device logging in. The cryptography involved in this process ensures that the proof can’t be spoofed.
